This question usually comes from someone taking on their first coastal or riverbank job. The logic seems sound: if it is a large bag being installed in water, surely it has to be waterproof or it will leak.
Some get as far as nearly ordering geobags to line a pond before thinking to ask. Asking first is lucky, because the result would have been nothing like what they expected. So, is a geobag waterproof? No. And it is precisely because it is not waterproof that a geobag does its job.
The Short Answer: Geobags Let Water Through
A geobag is made from geotextile fabric, either woven or non-woven depending on the design. That fabric is permeable, which means water passes through it.
What a geobag holds back is not water but the material inside it. Sand, aggregate or sediment stays contained while water moves freely in and out through the pores of the fabric.
So if the question is whether a geobag can hold water the way a pond liner does, the answer is clearly no. If the question is whether it can hold sand in place while waves keep hitting it, the answer is yes, and that is the job it was designed for.
Why Geobags Are Built to Let Water Through
This is the part that changes most people’s minds once they see it. Permeability is not a compromise or a weakness. It is a requirement for the system to work at all.
So the Bag Can Be Filled
Geobags are filled by pumping, not shovelling. What goes in is a slurry of sand and water.
Once inside, the water has to leave so that only sand remains. If the bag were waterproof, that slurry would stay as liquid mud inside, never consolidate, and the bag would never develop a stable shape or weight. Put simply, a waterproof bag cannot be filled this way at all.
So No Water Pressure Gets Trapped
Picture a sealed, waterproof bag filled and placed in a tidal zone. When the tide drops, external pressure falls while the pressure inside stays high.
That difference loads the fabric and the seams, and sooner or later it finds a way out through the weakest point. A permeable bag never faces this, because pressure inside and outside stay balanced.
There is also the question of uplift. A sealed bag holding a water and sand mixture is far more likely to be lifted by currents, while a geobag that has already drained is left with nothing but the weight of its sand.
So Wave Energy Is Absorbed Rather Than Reflected
A completely solid, sealed structure reflects waves. That reflection can scour the seabed in front of the structure and make the situation worse over time.
A permeable surface absorbs part of the wave energy instead of bouncing it back. For coastal protection work, this is a genuine advantage rather than a side effect.
What Actually Gets Specified on a Geobag / Geotextile Bag
Since waterproofing is not the goal, the specifications that matter are different from what people expect.
The first is soil retention. The fabric’s pore size has to be small enough to hold the sand being used, while remaining open enough to let water through. Too open and the sand escapes, so the bag slowly deflates. Too closed and filling becomes slow while internal pressure builds.
The second is tensile strength, because a single filled geobag can weigh a tonne or more. That load is carried entirely by the fabric and its seams.
The third is seam strength. This is often the real weak point, since no matter how strong the fabric is, the weakest join decides the outcome.
The fourth is UV resistance, which becomes critical for any geobag left exposed to sunlight without a protective cover.
Actual figures for all four come from the technical specification for each project, since they depend on wave conditions, the fill material, and how long the structure needs to last.
Three Products That Get Confused
Most of the confusion around waterproofing comes from three geosynthetic products with similar names and very different jobs.
Geobag
A bag made from geotextile fabric. It lets water through and holds fill material in. Sizes are manageable, and bags are filled then stacked or laid out according to the design.
Geomembrane
This is the waterproof one. A polyethylene sheet with very low permeability, used specifically to stop water seeping into the ground. It lines ponds, aquaculture ponds, reservoirs and landfill sites.
If your requirement is holding water in, geomembrane is what you are looking for, not a geobag.
Geotube/Geotextile Tube
The same family as a geobag, equally permeable and equally about retaining fill. The difference is shape and scale. A geotube is a long tube of considerable size, filled hydraulically, and generally used for longer structures such as breakwaters or reclamation dikes.
What to Use When You Genuinely Need Waterproofing
For any job that really does require water to be held, a geobag is not the answer.
Fish ponds, shrimp ponds, reservoirs, water storage and effluent treatment ponds all use geomembrane as the impermeable layer. In many cases a non-woven geotextile goes underneath as a cushion, protecting the membrane from sharp stones in the subgrade.
Interestingly, some projects use both together. The geomembrane holds the water while geobags retain material or protect the edges of the structure from scour. Two materials with opposite properties working within one system.
Where a Geobag Is the Right Choice
In coastal areas such as Bali, geobags are most commonly used to deal with erosion.
They are laid along a shoreline as a barrier, or placed at the toe of coastal structures to protect them from scour. Others are installed to stabilise banks at river mouths and along stretches where the current is cutting into the land.
What makes them suit these conditions is the fill material. Sand can be taken from the site itself, so there is no need to bring in large quantities of rock from elsewhere. In island regions, where freight often costs more than the material, that difference is substantial.
Other uses include sediment retention, protecting subsea pipes and cables, and smaller reclamation work. Smaller geobags are also used for dewatering sludge, working on exactly the same principle: water out, solids retained.
Permeability Is the Function, Not the Flaw
So when someone asks, is a geobag waterproof, the accurate answer is not simply no. It is no, and it should not be.
A geobag is designed to retain solid material while letting water pass. Everything about how it works rests on that single property. It can be filled by pump, it never stores trapped water pressure, it is less likely to be shifted by currents, and it absorbs wave energy instead of reflecting it.
If what you need is to hold water back, then geomembrane is the material. The two products come up in the same conversations often, yet their jobs are opposites.
And if you are putting together requirements for a project, the more useful question is not whether the material is waterproof. It is what actually needs to be held in place at that location. The answer to that points straight at the right product.
For more information about Geotextile Bag please contact: Whatsapp/Mobile Phone: +62 811 1721 338 (Ms. Ais) or Email : info@baligeotex.com